Monday, April 16, 2012

Speech Preparations


Since “alternative energy” isn’t exactly a problem, it’s hard to write a persuasive speech about it. For that reason, I have decided to take a slightly different turn for my term paper speech. I will know be speaking to persuade my audience that the United States of America needs to become less dependent on foreign oil. I plan on listing the multiple reasons that foreign oil dependency posses a problem to our country, such as ecological damage, economic damage, and even matters of national security.
There are two major plans for waning our reliance on foreign oil, one proposed by Robert Woolsey, and the other by T. Boone Pickens. The thing that really caught my eye about Woolsey’s plan is that it really does not advocate alternative energy off the bat. He believes that the technology to make alternative or renewable energy a viable replacement for foreign oil is still too expensive to be a realistic consideration. Instead, he advises that we should re-build the transportation industry. Require cars, trucks and busses to become more fuel efficient, build them with lighter materials so that they need smaller engines and less gas to run, and ultimately start spending less money importing foreign oil into our nation. I really like the idea of remaking the auto/transportation industry, though; I’d like to see this plan also at least make an attempt at establishing some sort of alternative energy source.
The plan proposed by T. Boone Pickens does just that, which is why I think this is the campaign that I am going to chose to advocate for in my speech. Under this plan, we would pursue many forms of alternative energy, most prominently wind energy, while also making a change to the transportation industry. What Pickens proposes is that we use wind energy to create electricity. The electricity that we create from the wind would be sufficient enough to replace the electricity that we currently derive from natural gas. After we free up some of our natural gas reserves, we would re-allocate it towards the transportation industry. Fueling our cars, commercial trucks, and/or busses with natural gas would have a direct impact on our dependency for foreign oil.
In my speech, I will frame the Pickens plan as being the best of both worlds. Not only does it call for reform of the transportation industry, but it also hopes to create new sources of domestic renewable energy. With the changes brought on by the Pickens plan, many jobs would be created for American citizens, and we would make a dent in the spending we use on imported oil, therefore, this plan may be just the plan we need to help get our economy back on track, as well as solving the problem of foreign dependency. 

1 comment:

  1. You are correct in pointing out how each of these plans contain valid and compelling ideas. For your speech, choose the proposal you like best and practice advocating for it - discuss the specific evidence, how it will work, etc.

    In your paper, you are to do a comparative analysis of two plans - not whether one is better or worse than the other - instead discussing strategies, how the issue is framed, how a particular audience is targeted, etc.

    I like your energy here. Remember: speech to practice advocacy; paper to compare strategies objectively.

    ReplyDelete